Label: Action Rezults Records (Available from CD Baby)
Released: 2007
To some extent, D’Edwin can get away with his unabashed mimicking of Morrissey, because he hasn’t graduated into the big leagues yet, but there has to be some substance to his music beyond a good Morrissey impression. On No Prognosis, that substance is erratic at best.
The opening track, “Secret Assassin,” does have some of that substance with an Eastern influence and wind instruments providing an ambient backdrop. However, even this, the album’s best song, falls into the trap that so many find themselves in when artists work alone in these days of inexpensive electronic effects. (It’s the same trap that D’Edwin falls into as a graphic artist when he committed his Photoshop sins on the album cover.) If you’re bothered by the double-tracked vocals, that’s nothing compared to the birds singing in “I Don’t Recall.” The bottom line is that you can’t fill out your sound with effects in lieu of a band. If in doubt, err on the side of simplicity and D’Edwin, albeit far from the worst offender, errs on the side of over-processing. He takes a decent song like the opener or the EP’s more organic final track, “I Abhor,” and makes it sound more amateur than it is.
However, most of the songs do remain listenable if you have any affinity for 80s alternative music and you’re willing to grant D’Edwin a few indulgences for inexperience, lack of funds or any other excuse that seems plausible. There is one track though that cannot be excused. Anyone with any ear at all can recognize that “Lazy Train” should never have seen the light of day. D’Edwin’s small foray into techno, the song displays a book knowledge of how techno songs are built and absolutely no ability to actually build one.
All that being said, I actually enjoyed this album on some level, partly because I like the Smiths and partly because it reminds me of some of the underground post-punk experimentation of the 80s. Plus, D’Edwin isn’t without talent. The first and last tracks have real potential and assuming that his well isn’t dry so much as it isn’t fully tapped for a consistent flow, he certainly could grow. Still, none of these things actually make No Prognosis good.
Rating: 4/10